verifiability principle

verifiability principle
the doctrine that if a nonanalytic statement is to be cognitively meaningful it must be empirically verifiable.

* * *

Criterion of meaningfulness associated with logical positivism and the Vienna Circle.

Moritz Schlick's formulation "The meaning of a [declarative sentence] is the method of its verification" was close to the view held in pragmatism, and later in operationalism, that an assertion has factual meaning only if there is a difference in principle, open to test by observation, between the affirmation and the denial of the assertion. Thus, the statements of ethics, metaphysics, religion, and aesthetics were held to be meaningless. The verifiability criterion of meaningfulness was in part inspired by Albert Einstein's abandonment of the ether hypothesis and the notion of absolute simultaneity.

* * *

      a philosophical doctrine fundamental to the school of Logical Positivism holding that a statement is meaningful only if it is either empirically verifiable or else tautological (i.e., such that its truth arises entirely from the meanings of its terms). Thus, the principle discards as meaningless the metaphysical statements of traditional philosophy as well as other kinds of statements—such as ethical, aesthetic, or religious principles—asserted as true but neither tautological nor known from experience. Such statements may have meaning in the sense of being able to influence feelings, beliefs, or conduct but not in the sense of being true or false and hence of imparting knowledge. According to the principle, then, a nontautological statement has meaning only if some set of observable conditions is relevant to determining its truth or falsity; so stated, it reflects the view that the meaning of a statement is the set of conditions under which it would be true.

      Disagreement among Positivists has arisen over the kinds of conditions that qualify as observable for purposes of verification and the exact nature of their relevance to the truth or falsity of statements. While Hans Reichenbach has maintained that verifying observations must be physically possible or compatible with the known laws of science, it has been more widely held that they need only be logically possible or conceivable in a noncontradictory way. Early exponents of the view that observation reports provide an indubitably certain foundation for knowledge held that verifiability requires that a statement be logically entailed by some finite set of observation reports. Later Positivists, having abandoned this view, have required of a verifiable statement only that it be made evident or supported or rendered probable by the relevant set of observations.

      The principal criticism of the verifiability principle has been that, because it is not an empirical proposition, it is itself on its own terms either meaningless or else tautologically true as an arbitrary definition of meaningfulness. In response, it has been argued both that the principle is indeed a tautology, though a nonarbitrary one in that it reflects actual usage and that it is strictly meaningless but to be taken as a recommendation for the conduct of scientific inquiry.

* * *

Universalium. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • verifiability principle — noun The principle, especially in 20th century empiricism, that a statement has meaning if, and only if, either it can be verified by means of empirical observations or it is logically true by definition. It is generally agreed among most… …   Wiktionary

  • verifiability principle — noun or verifiability theory : a proposal or claim of early logical positivists according to which a requirement or criterion for the meaningfulness of a factual statement is its susceptibility to the possibility of being either theoretically or… …   Useful english dictionary

  • verification/verifiability principle —    The central principle of logical positivism, the verification principle states that the meaning of non analytic statements is found in their conditions of verification. On this view, all non analytical statements that do not have verification… …   Christian Philosophy

  • principle — /prin seuh peuhl/, n. 1. an accepted or professed rule of action or conduct: a person of good moral principles. 2. a fundamental, primary, or general law or truth from which others are derived: the principles of modern physics. 3. a fundamental… …   Universalium

  • principle, verifiability —    see verification/verifiability principle …   Christian Philosophy

  • verifiability theory — noun see verifiability principle …   Useful english dictionary

  • principle, verification —    see verification/verifiability principle …   Christian Philosophy

  • falsification principle —    Suggested by Karl Popper, the falsification principle distinguishes scientific statements from non scientific statements in virtue of their conceivable falsification. A highly influential application of the principle to religion is found in… …   Christian Philosophy

  • verification principle — (or verifiability principle ) The principle central to logical positivism, according to which the meaning of a statement is its method of verification. Sentences apparently expressing propositions that admit of no verification (such as those of… …   Philosophy dictionary

  • verification principle — noun or verification theory : verifiability principle * * * verification principle noun (in logical positivism) the principle that a statement is meaningful only if its truth or falsity can be established empirically • • • Main Entry: ↑verify …   Useful english dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.